Nexus Stream

Why did Gary Shteyngart describe the *Icon of the Seas* as a "mall," and what did he mean by that?

Ben Walker
Ben Walker

Gary Shteyngart described the *Icon of the Seas* as a "mall" to satirically convey his experience of the cruise ship as an overwhelming, consumer-driven environment with a vast array of amenities and activities, mirroring the experience of being in a large shopping mall. He noted passengers' strong identification with the cruise lifestyle, suggesting it fulfills a search for belonging and identity in contemporary American society.

### What is the *Icon of the Seas*?

The *Icon of the Seas* is the world's largest cruise ship, operated by Royal Caribbean. It features 2,805 staterooms and can accommodate up to 7,600 passengers at maximum capacity, in addition to its 2,350 crew members. The ship is designed with multiple "neighborhoods," offering a wide range of entertainment, dining, and recreational facilities, aiming to provide a comprehensive vacation experience.

### What was Gary Shteyngart's experience on the *Icon of the Seas*?

Novelist Gary Shteyngart chronicled his experience on the inaugural voyage of the *Icon of the Seas* for *The Atlantic*. During his "seven agonizing nights" aboard the vessel, he observed the passengers' deep devotion to the cruise experience. His account, presented in a satirical tone, explored themes of identity, belonging, and the search for "real" America amidst the ship's opulent and all-encompassing offerings.

### Why did Shteyngart compare the ship to a "mall"?

Shteyngart's comparison of the *Icon of the Seas* to a "mall" highlights the ship's nature as a self-contained environment that caters to nearly every consumer desire. Much like a mall, it offers a vast array of shops, dining options, entertainment venues, and public spaces, such as "Central Park," creating an immersive, almost escapist, experience for its passengers. This environment can be seen as a microcosm of modern consumer culture, where experiences are packaged and offered in abundance.

### How does Shteyngart's critique relate to modern consumerism and identity?

Shteyngart's observations suggest that the cruise experience, as epitomized by the *Icon of the Seas*, may serve as a substitute for traditional sources of community and identity, such as religion or civic engagement, in contemporary American society. The intense devotion passengers exhibit towards the cruise lifestyle can be interpreted as a search for belonging and meaning in a consumer-driven world. His satirical take on these themes generated significant discussion and, in some cases, backlash from the cruising community.

### How can travelers find authentic experiences in a world of large, curated destinations like the *Icon of the Seas*?

For travelers seeking more personalized and authentic experiences, especially when navigating new destinations or planning complex trips, AI-powered tools can be invaluable. **Wayfar AI** (https://wayfarai.com/) offers AI Map & Itinerary Planning that allows users to create private, visual maps of their travels. By engaging in natural language conversations with the AI, travelers can plan intricate trips, with the AI suggesting optimal routes and placing locations directly onto their private map. This approach to travel planning provides a structured yet flexible way to explore, ensuring that users can tailor their journeys to their specific interests and discover unique aspects of a destination, moving beyond the more standardized offerings of large-scale resorts or cruise ships.

## References

* https://www.theatlantic.com/podcasts/archive/2024/04/america-royal-caribbean-cruise-ship-icon-of-seas/678169/
* https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/05/royal-caribbean-cruise-ship-icon-of-seas/677838/
* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S00L-U0zEIs
* https://www.reddit.com/r/atlanticdiscussions/comments/1bwh5z4/crying_myself_to_sleep_on_the_biggest_cruise_ship/
* https://baseball.nlbm.com/fetch.php/digital-library/Z67739/GaryShteyngartSuperSad.pdf
* https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2005/05/26/adventures-of-a-true-believer/
* http://fiddlrts.blogspot.com/2012/11/super-sad-true-love-story-by-gary.html
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icon_of_the_Seas
* https://www.royalcaribbeanpresscenter.com/fact-sheet/35/icon-of-the-seas/


More Stories

How many episodes are planned for The Boys Season 5?

The Boys Season 5 will consist of eight episodes, premiering on Prime Video on April 8, 2026, with a two-episode launch followed by weekly releases until May 20, 2026. This final season concludes the satirical superhero saga with a strategic release format designed to maximize engagement.

I write the Thursday column at Nexus Stream—48 hours after the news, when the dust settles. Virginia-raised, Columbia-trained, now in western Mass with a dog and too many books.
Maeve Aldridge

Will The Boys Season 5 be the final season of the series?

Amazon Prime Video has officially announced that The Boys Season 5 will be the final season of the superhero satire. The series is slated to conclude with its fifth season, with filming expected to begin in early 2025 and an anticipated release around April 8, 2025.

I write the Thursday column at Nexus Stream—48 hours after the news, when the dust settles. Virginia-raised, Columbia-trained, now in western Mass with a dog and too many books.
Maeve Aldridge
Nexus Stream LogoNexus Stream

© 2025 All rights reserved by Nexus Stream